New York Bagelry Menu

New York Bagelry is a beloved establishment in Reading, PA, known for its delicious and fresh bagels and sandwiches. Offering a variety of options for breakfast and lunch, including unique flavors like Apple Cinnamon and Blueberry, their menu caters to both meat-eaters and vegetarians. Customers rave about the quality of the food, with one reviewer mentioning the standout items like the Super-Egg Bagel and seasonal flavors like Pumpkin. The friendly staff and efficient service make dining in or taking out a breeze. While some customers note minor inconsistencies in bagel shapes, overall, New York Bagelry stands out as a top choice for those craving authentic New York-style bagels. So, whether you're a local looking for a hometown favorite or a bagel connoisseur seeking a satisfying meal, New York Bagelry is sure to exceed your expectations.

Breakfast Sandwiches

2 Piece Eggs

$2.89

Taylor Ham

Bagel Choice: Cinnamon Raisin, Multi Grain, Poppy, Sesame

$3.79

Italian

Bagels Choice: Apple Cinnamon, Asiago, Black Russian, Blueberry, Chocolate Chip. Side Choice: Chips, Deli Pickle. Peppers Choice: Hot Peppers, Sweet Peppers

$7.45

Half Pizza Bagel

Bagels Choice: Apple Cinnamon, Asiago, Black Russian, Blueberry, Chocolate Chip. Side Choice: Chips, Deli Pickle. Peppers Choice: Hot Peppers, Sweet Peppers

$2.19

Lunch Sandwiches

Bagels

Bagel Bundle

14 bagels, 1-2 pound plain cream cheese, 1-2 pound flavored cream cheese. Bagels Choice: Apple Cinnamon, Asiago, Black Russian, Blueberry, Chocolate Chip

$17.99

Bagel (1)

Bagels Choice: Apple Cinnamon, Asiago, Black Russian, Blueberry, Chocolate Chip

$2.81

Peppercorn Turkey

$12.49

Provolone Cheese

$9.99

By the Pound

Beverages

Icy Tea

Assorted varieties

$1.25

Bottled Soda (24 Oz.)

Soda Choice: Coke, Diet Coke, Sprite

$1.75