• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Welcome to New York Bagelry

In the heart of Reading, PA, New York Bagelry stands out as a must-visit spot for bagel lovers. With a wide array of flavors, from classic to seasonal, their bagels are always fresh and delicious, earning high praise from loyal customers. The friendly staff and prompt service provide a welcoming experience, whether you choose to dine in or grab your meal on the go. While some customers note minor inconsistencies in bagel shapes, the overall quality and taste make up for it. Offering a variety of menu options, including breakfast and lunch sandwiches, as well as catering services, New York Bagelry truly lives up to its reputation as a top-notch bagel shop in the area.

New York Bagelry: Reviews & Ratings

Jenn A.
Jenn A.

Always fresh and delicious! The prices are incredibly reasonable, especially for the high quality food you receive. I am extremely impressed by the quality of the bagels every time we order and am frequently recommending this establishment to others. The cream cheese and salads are also excellent and always fresh. I love the variety of options and have multiple favorite menu items as I've been a customer for almost 2 decades now! Service has always been prompt, professional, and reliable. Our catering orders are given with confidence of the delivery of satisfaction. Fast paced and ease of counter service or drive thru options make this a perfect fit for those who wish to relax inside or take a meal on the go! My top bagel recommendations are: The super-egg or everything bagel The seasonal flavors (especially pumpkin!) The French Toast bagel Other menu favorites include: The seafood salad The Egg Salad Seasonal Cream Cheeses Swing by and enjoy a bite... you won't be disappointed!

Dstrock73 ..
Dstrock73 ..

Spending 10 years in the UWS of Manhattan and frequenting H&H bagels, I had become very critical of a good bagel. Now that I live in Berks County PA, my standards have dropped quite a bit. New York Bagelry makes a very good tasting bagel that is far superior to any other bagel place in the Reading/Berks area, but they could put just a little more effort into their consistency. Although they consistently make a round bagel, the shape within that circle tends to be all over the place. Service is always great! The place looks exactly how it should look for a bagel place. Note to the owner- I come about once every two weeks and always order a dozen bagels with a small cream cheese. You would absolutely make my day if all 14 bagels had similar, if not identical shape. What can I say, I am a very simple man!

Sydney K.
Sydney K.

There was a huge line so I was excited to see what I was missing out on. The cashier was very polite and took our order quickly. Bagel sandwiches were a little expensive, but definitely worth it! I will definitely be a returning customer.

Jean Elie P.
Jean Elie P.

Best bagel shop in the area !!!! Ny style bagels and great staff ! Super clean I highly recommend them to anyone missing Ny style breakfast

Kini N.
Kini N.

Hometown institution that's been here for many, many years!! They have such a good menu with different flavors of bagels and cream cheese. Whether you order inside or from the drive thru, you'll never been disappointed!

Beth F.
Beth F.

Best bagel sandwich shop in Pennsylvania! They may even give New York City a run for their money. I have been eating here since high school. I highly recommend giving it a try!

Daniel V.
Daniel V.

On our way to phl from reading we stopped on the recommendation from a good friend. Best bagel egg sausage sammitch I've ever had. Had a cold clover farms chocolate milk and left with a tasty pumpkin spice hot drink for the journey ahead. Counter was fast and friendly with great suggestions. My everything bagelwich rocked! Clean no frills good food.

Location

New York Bagelry: A Taste of Authentic NY Bagels in Reading, PA

If you're looking for a taste of authentic New York-style bagels in Reading, PA, look no further than New York Bagelry. Located at 2720 Penn Ave, this bagel haven offers a variety of mouthwatering options that are sure to satisfy your cravings.

From breakfast sandwiches like the Taylor Ham Bagel to lunch sandwiches like the Italian Bagels, there is something for everyone at New York Bagelry. Their bagel bundles, including 14 bagels and cream cheese, are perfect for sharing with friends and family.

Customer reviews rave about the freshness and deliciousness of the food at New York Bagelry. Jenn A. mentions that the prices are incredibly reasonable for the high-quality food you receive, while Dstrock73 appreciates the superior taste of the bagels compared to other places in the area.

Service at New York Bagelry is always prompt and professional, making it a go-to spot for those looking for a quick and satisfying meal. Whether you dine in or take your meal to go, you can always count on a great experience at New York Bagelry.

So, if you're craving a delicious, authentic NY-style bagel in Reading, be sure to stop by New York Bagelry. You won't be disappointed!